Plaintiffs in a lawsuit claiming that the Palo Alto Unified School District encouraged students to wear Islamic religious attire for a field trip to a mosque have missed court filing deadlines since they submitted the case in August.
Community Members for Religious Neutrality in Public Schools, which includes parents of Palo Alto High School students and residents of neighboring cities, alleged that the school district infringed on the students’ freedom of speech, unfairly favored a particular religion and violated privacy laws, among other claims.
Judge Virginia DeMarchi, who was assigned to oversee the case, said that the plaintiffs failed to submit several required documents, she wrote in a Nov. 5 statement. The plaintiffs did not file a joint case management statement by Nov. 3, nor did they serve a defendant, DeMarchi wrote.
She gave the plaintiffs an opportunity to submit the missing materials by Nov. 9 before moving to drop the case.
“Plaintiffs shall file a response to this order advising of the status service of process on defendants and showing cause why the Court should not recommend dismissal of the action,” DeMarchi wrote in a statement.
Plaintiffs met that deadline by submitting documents showing they served the Palo Alto Unified School District and providing an update on the status of the case.
Plaintiffs wrote in a statement that they are still negotiating with the district on whether Palo Alto High School Principal Brent Kline should be included as a defendant. They asked for an extended deadline of Nov. 16 to serve Kline. As of Monday afternoon, plaintiffs had yet to submit additional documentation showing that they served Kline.
“Plaintiffs’ counsel apologizes for the delay in getting this case underway,” the plaintiffs wrote in a statement.
The lawsuit, which zeroed in on the district’s Social Justice Pathway, has since garnered international media coverage and critical responses from figures like Elon Musk.
Palo Alto Unified’s Social Justice Pathway is an elective three-year program that allows high school students to take classes focused on global issues. Within the program, students take a field trip to a local mosque – a move that the federal lawsuit claimed led to multiple violations of the law.
The parents claimed that students “were exposed to messaging that portrayed Islam as uniquely aligned with social justice work,” the lawsuit reads.
“Female students were provided hijabs to wear and that all students were gifted Qurans to take home for personal use,” the lawsuit reads. “Students were photographed during the visit by the Islamic institution hosting the event in a manner that promoted participation in Islamic custom.”
Plaintiffs also alleged that parents were not provided “meaningful” opportunities to authorize their student’s participation in the field trip.
Amid the deluge of media attention on the lawsuit, Palo Alto High School student journalists said they felt as though the coverage did not accurately represent the nuances of the pathway. Further, Palo Alto High School students who attended the field trip reported that they did not feel pressured to participate in class activities, according to a Paly Voice article.
The district has not yet responded to the lawsuit and Superintendent Jason Glass previously told this publication that he could not provide comment on pending litigation.
“What I can say is what our board policy requires,” Glass said. “Instruction about religion in our schools must be academic, not devotional. No faith may be promoted, and no faith may be denigrated. Every family in this district is entitled to expect that standard, and I will review our practice against it.”
The initial case management conference was postponed from Nov. 10 to Jan. 5, 2027, and plaintiffs plan to submit an updated complaint next week.
Lisa Moreno is a journalist who grew up in the East Bay Area. She completed her Bachelor's degree in Print and Online Journalism with a minor in Latino studies from San Francisco State University in 2024.... More by Lisa Moreno